A Look Back at the Legacy of Smith & Wesson
The world of firearms is filled with iconic models, each with its own legacy and dedicated following. Among the most respected names, Smith & Wesson reigns supreme, especially when it comes to revolvers. These reliable and powerful handguns have a history deeply woven into the fabric of law enforcement, self-defense, and sport shooting. Within the Smith & Wesson lineup, two models frequently capture the attention of enthusiasts: the 686 and the 686 Plus. Both revolvers represent the pinnacle of Smith & Wesson’s craftsmanship, but understanding their nuanced differences is crucial for selecting the right tool for your needs. This article delves into a detailed comparison, offering a comprehensive guide to help you decide which Smith & Wesson revolver – the 686 or the 686 Plus – deserves a place in your collection.
Exploring the Key Features of the 686
The Smith & Wesson 686, a classic embodiment of the L-frame design, is a testament to the brand’s engineering prowess. Constructed primarily from stainless steel, the 686 boasts exceptional durability and resistance to the elements. This rugged construction makes it a dependable choice for various applications, from range practice to field carry. The use of stainless steel also gives the revolver a sleek, timeless aesthetic.
The 686 is typically chambered in the versatile and potent .357 Magnum, as well as the more economical .38 Special. This dual capability allows for a wide range of ammunition choices, catering to both practice and defensive needs. The heavier .357 Magnum is ideal for self-defense and hunting, offering significant stopping power, while .38 Special rounds provide a softer recoil experience, making them perfect for extended range sessions.
A defining characteristic of the 686 is its cylinder capacity, holding a respectable number of cartridges. The cylinder’s design and overall balance contribute to the revolver’s smooth operation and renowned reliability. It provides a comfortable grip and intuitive handling. The availability of various barrel lengths, from compact concealed-carry options to longer-barreled target models, offers adaptability for different shooting styles and preferences.
Furthermore, the 686 is typically equipped with adjustable sights, allowing for precise aiming and fine-tuning of the point of impact. These adjustable sights are crucial for achieving optimal accuracy, especially in target shooting or hunting scenarios. Grips also come in a variety of materials and designs, allowing users to customize the ergonomics to match their hand size and shooting style.
A key strength is its proven track record of reliability and ruggedness. It’s built to withstand years of use, whether at the range or in demanding field conditions. Its weight helps absorb recoil, making it manageable even with powerful .357 Magnum loads. The 686 is known for its inherent accuracy, allowing shooters to place shots with precision. Its straightforward design makes it simple to operate and maintain, making it an ideal choice for both experienced shooters and those new to revolvers. Finally, the classic and elegant design of the 686 continues to appeal to shooters of all backgrounds.
Examining the Key Features of the 686 Plus
Building upon the solid foundation of the 686, the 686 Plus introduces a significant enhancement: a larger cylinder capacity. The basic principles remain consistent, maintaining the same quality construction, material choices, and the overall reliability that defines the L-frame platform.
Like the 686, the 686 Plus is constructed from durable stainless steel, ensuring longevity and resilience. It also offers similar barrel length options, adjustable sights, and grip choices, providing customization to suit individual shooting preferences. The chambering options, too, are identical, making it compatible with both .357 Magnum and .38 Special ammunition.
However, the most notable distinction is the cylinder capacity. The 686 Plus can hold a higher round count, enhancing its utility in various applications. This enhancement provides a distinct advantage when it comes to defensive situations or extended shooting sessions.
The increased capacity of the 686 Plus does not drastically alter the overall feel or handling of the revolver. It retains the same ergonomic design, ensuring a comfortable grip and user-friendly experience. The sights remain the same, maintaining the same high level of accuracy. The barrel length variations still provide options for different use cases.
The advantages of the 686 Plus extend beyond the added capacity. It maintains the same unwavering reliability, recoil-managing capabilities, and inherent accuracy of the original 686. It is still simple to operate and features that classic design. The larger capacity simply makes it better suited for specific users and situations.
A Direct Comparison: Unveiling the Key Differences
When considering the 686 and 686 Plus, the core distinction lies in the capacity of the cylinder. The 686 holds a specific number of rounds, whereas the 686 Plus offers an enhanced number of rounds. This difference might seem subtle, but it has ramifications depending on the intended use of the revolver.
The difference in the number of rounds translates to an increased number of available shots before reloading. In self-defense situations, this can provide a valuable advantage. For extended range sessions, it means fewer reloads, allowing for more continuous practice.
The weight of the revolvers is not dramatically different, but even a slight increase can affect the handling and balance of the firearm. While the 686 and 686 Plus share similar external dimensions, the added rounds can contribute to a slight increase in weight.
The potential impact of this extra weight on felt recoil is also worth considering. A slightly heavier handgun might absorb recoil more effectively, especially when using powerful .357 Magnum ammunition, leading to improved control and follow-up shot accuracy. However, the differences are likely to be minimal for the average shooter.
Another factor is related to practical considerations like loading and unloading. Both models are compatible with speed loaders, which can significantly speed up the reloading process.
The price difference is not significant, and the cost of a revolver depends on many things. Factors such as the specific configuration, included features, and market demand can all influence the final cost.
The Impact on Your Chosen Path: Applications in Focus
Understanding the ideal applications of the 686 and 686 Plus is crucial to making an informed decision. The intended use of the revolver will often dictate which model is the better choice.
If self-defense is your primary concern, the increased round capacity of the 686 Plus offers a potential advantage. The ability to have more rounds at the ready can provide added peace of mind in a high-stress encounter. However, the difference might be negligible for experienced shooters, and the reliability and accuracy of both models remain paramount.
For target shooting, both revolvers excel. Their accuracy, comfortable grips, and manageable recoil make them excellent choices for plinking, target practice, and even competitive shooting. The choice between the two might come down to personal preference and how frequently you reload during your shooting sessions.
The .357 Magnum chambering of both models makes them suitable for hunting applications, particularly for medium-sized game. The choice here might depend on local regulations, the type of game being hunted, and the shooter’s familiarity with the firearm. Both revolvers deliver the stopping power needed to take down game humanely.
Whether you are looking to get into range shooting or you want to add to your collection, these revolvers will be a great addition.
A Concise Summary: Highlighting the Strengths and Weaknesses
To assist in your decision-making process, here’s a concise summary of the pros and cons:
For the 686, the advantages include proven reliability, excellent recoil management, a reputation for accuracy, and a classic design. However, the drawback is its smaller round count.
For the 686 Plus, the advantages include the increased capacity, reliability, accuracy, and user-friendly design. However, the added rounds can result in more weight.
Making the Right Choice: Which Smith & Wesson Should You Pick?
The ideal choice comes down to individual needs.
If the ability to quickly and effectively respond to threats is your primary focus, and you prioritize the maximum number of rounds available, the 686 Plus may be the better choice. The advantage of having the extra rounds can be important in a self-defense situation.
For those seeking a reliable and accurate revolver for range shooting, target practice, or hunting, the 686 is an excellent choice. The proven track record of reliability and its well-balanced design are major advantages.
Personal preference also plays a significant role. Consider the weight, balance, and feel of each revolver in your hand. Handle both models at a local gun store if possible. The best firearm is the one that feels most comfortable and inspires the most confidence.
Price, of course, is another factor to consider. Compare the cost of both models and factor in any additional accessories you might need. Regardless of the choice, both revolvers have a strong reputation for reliability and accuracy.
The Final Word
In the realm of revolvers, the Smith & Wesson 686 and 686 Plus stand out as exceptional examples of firearm craftsmanship. Both share a common heritage of quality, reliability, and performance, making them desirable choices for shooters of all experience levels. The decision between the two hinges on a single, but significant, factor: the capacity of the cylinder. Ultimately, the choice should align with your individual requirements, ensuring that you select a revolver that empowers you with confidence.
Remember, safety is paramount. Always handle firearms responsibly, and follow all applicable safety guidelines. The best way to be confident in your choice is to get hands-on experience with both models if possible.
Choosing the right handgun is a personal decision. Consider your intended use, handling characteristics, and personal preferences.
